Call Us

Calling the number above will direct you to a licensed sales agent.

Email Us

Call Michelle    

MEDICARE PLANNING

Whether you are looking for Medicare Supplement Insurance, Medicare Part D Drug program or a Medicare Advantage plan…

Dental, Vision & Hearing

Most folks don’t think about the fact that when you retire you lose your dental/vision coverage. We are proud…

Life, Disability & LTC

Long-term care (LTC) is a range of services and support for your personal care needs. Most long-term care…

Retirement and Financial Planning

One of our biggest fears is outliving our money. Let us show you how your…

Divider

WELCOME TO THE McPIKE INSURANCE AGENCY

“We don’t sell insurance – we help people buy it.”

We have been serving clients for over 46 years as independent agents contracted with many insurance companies selling all lines of insurance. Our objective is to fully understand your needs and circumstances before proposing any products and making sure you understand the pluses and minuses of your options.  We are dedicated to keeping up with a constant changing environment through continuing education in order to better serve you. 

We provide free face-to-face and phone consultations and welcome the opportunity to assist you with your planning.  Our client retention rate is over 95% and we are committed to helping each one through those “tough times” that will occur now and then.

We offer plans from these fine companies…

Senior Health carriers: Aetna, Anthem, Centene Corporation, Humana, IU Health, Medico, Mutual of Omaha, United Healthcare and Wellcare.

Life & Disability carriers:  Ameritas, Illinois Mutual, Lincoln Financial Group, MetLife, Midland National, North American, Principal, Protective, Prudential and TransAmerica.

Calling the number above will direct you to a licensed sales agent.

Divider

Products

McPike Insurance is licensed to sell Medicare Supplement insurance. We’re a full-service insurance agency providing Financial Planning, Health, and Life insurance in addition to Medicare Advantage coverage plans.  

Ballard Insurance Medicare

Medicare Planning

When you are looking for Medicare options, let us take the hassle out of shopping around…

McPike Insurance Agency

Dental, Vision & Hearing

Most folks don’t think about the fact that when you retire you lose your dental/vision coverage. We are proud…

McPike Insurance Agency

Life, Disability & LTC

Long-term care (LTC) is a range of services and support for your personal care needs. Most long-term care…

service 4

Retirement and Financial Planning

One of our biggest fears is outliving our money. Let us show you how your…

Divider

Client Reviews - What Others Say About Us

As a newly retired professional still under the age of 65, Michelle was extremely helpful assisting me with navigating the marketplace for the very first time.
My insurance agent was extremely helpful and professional. They took the time to explain everything clearly and made sure I found the right coverage for my needs. I really appreciate their patience and support.”
Michelle came highly recommended to us as a Medicare professional. Having worked with her in the past, for other insurance needs, we were aware of her integrity. Our Medicare experience thus far has been very pleasant as a result of her in-depth knowledge of the subject matter, flexibility in schedule and her gift of effective communication.
McPike Insurance, LLC was very helpful to me when I needed health insurance and they went above and beyond to find what I could afford and they were so nice and kind and I would highly recommend them.
McPike insurance is great to work with. Very knowledgeable, prompt and friendly. Highly recommended.
Michelle is a great insurance agent. She is always available to answer questions and help our family. Thank you!
Michelle and her team have always provided me with updated information and plan options in choosing the best insurance for my situation. I never have to worry about Michelle not answering my emails or texts in a timely manner. I would strongly suggest her business to anyone.
Michelle has provided extraordinary service as she guided me through the transition to Medicare and beyond. I would recommend her to anyone that will soon be facing that challenge.

Stan Boultinghouse
McPike Insurance is very knowledgeable and dependable. I have moved to two different states with different Medicare plans since initially working with them in Indiana. They have been there for me every step negotiating which plan was best for me and always in a timely fashion. I highly recommend them for your insurance needs!
Insurance rep was very professional.
She explained all my options and worked with me to get the best plan based on my needs.
Would highly recommend this agency.
Michelle helped both my wife and me to transition to a much more affordable Medicare plan. It will save us a few thousand dollars in just one year and it provides excellent coverage. She took great pains to help us understand our options and the complex issues that surround such decisions. We are thankful for her professional assistance.
Just want to mention that if you have any questions concerning your Medicare coverage I would recommend Michelle McPike Moran to help you. She does an excellent job, and is well versed in what is available to you. I've know and done business with her and her family for over 30 years. I highly recommend her.
Michelle helped me navigate the Medicare maze! She was more focused on making sure I got the coverage for my needs rather than selling a particular product. Once she understood my history and concerns, she found the right product for me at an affordable price. Michelle will be my agent for life!
Response from the owner:Thank you for allowing me to help you, Terri!
MIchelle was informed and responsive when providing Medicare supplements for my brother and me. I appreciated her knowledge and willingness to help.
Michelle has done a wonderful job helping us navigate into very affordable Medicare insurance during our retirement years, even after we became Florida residents. She is very knowledgeable and efficient in her explanation of the various insurance options. She was also very gracious of her time as she drove 60 miles to meet with my mother and answer her medical insurance questions after my father's passing. I would highly recommend Michelle!
Michelle was such a valuable and helpful asset to have when deciding on my husband's and my Medicare options. She explained everything very clearly, and believe me, we had a lot of questions. When something changed with my husband's insurance, she helped us get to the correct policy. I would definitely recommend Michelle for your Medicare needs.
Awesome rep so glad I have been blessed with her knowledge & support wouldn't use anyone else
Michelle came to our home, was very friendly, informative and changed our insurance on the spot. Thank you 😊
Response from the owner:Glad to help, Rebecca!
I have had Pike for a few years moving from IN to MI and Michelle has been very helpful during my different transitions. Ive even had to change insurance within state. I highly recommend them
Response from the owner:Thank you, Pamela!
We have been going to McPike Insurance ever since we reached retirement age. Randy, and currently Michelle, have been like family in their concern for our insurance needs. The yearly meetings we have to keep us informed are much appreciated. None of our other insurance providers do that. They have exhibited nothing but kindness, generosity of time, clear presentation of information and patience with making sure that we, as their friends and clients, are fully taken care of.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Paula! Your trust and friendship are never taken for granted. We’re always here to make sure you feel informed and well cared for.
Great knowledge of medicare options for seniors, dedicated to finding best option for each individual.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Larry!
Michelle at McPike Insurance was very helpful as we transitioned into retirement and into the new world of Medicare and supplemental insurance.
Response from the owner:Thank you! It's been a pleasure helping you with the retirement transition, Mike.
Highly recommended. Michelle worked with me to get my insurance set up when I retired. She was very knowledgeable and through and helped work through all the problems that came up due to my former workplace. I trust her totally with my insurance needs.
Response from the owner:Thank you for the kind words, Sherry!
Michelle has always been quick to respond to questions and helpful when needed. Glad I chose McPike Insurance to help me with my Medicare supplement
Response from the owner:Thanks, Kevin, for the kind words!
Michelle is knowledgeable and willing to answer all your questions.
Response from the owner:Lu, thank you for your kind words!
Michelle McPike Morin is very knowledgeable and helpful in assisting us with our Medicare options and sign up. We appreciate her expertise and highly recommend her.
Response from the owner:Jay, thank you so much for the kind words.
She takes the time to explain the plans and the differences about how they work for you.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Bob!
Michelle is very focused on helping those in need of some sound information.
In a world that is full of mis-information, she is a breath of Fresh Air.
Thanks for all you do....
Highly recommend Michelle for all those that need a little Fresh Air.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Norman! In a time when clear, reliable information matters more than ever, it means a lot to be seen as a helpful resource.
Michelle has done great work for us. She is very knowledgable about the medicare plans available in our area. She answers all our questions and works hard to find any information we need to make good choices for our healthcare. I highly recommend Michele and her agency. agency.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much, Lynn, for your thoughtful review! It has been a pleasure working with you and Mike.
Michelle is very knowledgeable & up to date on all insurance, she takes the time to go over everything with you, without rushing you & answering all questions & explaining in details what is needed & best decision you can make for your health issues & explain all options in details
Response from the owner:Elaine, thank you so much for your kind words! Taking the time to answer questions and make sure you feel confident in your decisions is exactly what we strive for at McPike Insurance.
I have worked with Bob, Randy and Michelle for many years! I cant say enough good things about them! They are all caring knowledgeable, kind honest good people.They answer your questions and if they don’t know right away they find out. I have never had any problems with the McPikes, as agents or as Friends. If you need Insurance give them a call! They will be happy to help you!😃.
Response from the owner:Linda, thank you so much for your kind words and for trusting Bob, Randy, Michelle, and our team over the years. We truly appreciate your loyalty and the friendship that’s grown along the way.
Michelle McPike Morin has been very good at making sure every year we are signed up for our Medicare part C-Advantage plan. She makes sure we are getting the best deal we can get.
Response from the owner:Ken, thank you for the kind review! I appreciate your trust in me to help you each year.
Great customer service & support from McPike!
After my accident 2 years ago I couldn’t have had better! If someone needs anything Michele will be right there to answer your questions.
Response from the owner:Marilyn, thank you so much for the kind words. We’re grateful you’ve felt supported, especially during such a tough time after your accident.
I was nervous approaching Medicare decision time. A coworker recommended Michelle and that was the greatest referral I ever received. Michelle walked us through our options and helped set everything up for us. Every subsequent year at renewal time, I hear from her as far as recommendations going forward. A new friend for life!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for sharing this, Rick! I appreciate your trust and friendship!
Michelle has been very helpful and knowledgeable in meeting my and my husband’s Medicare insurance needs. She responds to inquires speedily and give accurate information, allowing us to make important decisions easily. I highly recommend her services!
I highly recommend McPike insurance. I tend to have a lot of questions and Michelle is very patient and thorough with her answers. I've been very happy with McPike Insurance!
McPike Insurance has helped both me and my late wife for years. First with Michelle's father and then with Michelle. Personal visits and office visits were always pleasant and helpful. They are good people!
Response from the owner:It has been a pleasure working with you for many years, John!
I've been with this family-owned insurance agency for many years. In this complex world of insurance, I feel confident that I have an agent who is knowledgeable and prompt in responding.
Response from the owner:We appreciate and value your business!
Michelle is very informative, which is very helpful when working with insurance needs, it’s so confusing. She always answers questions
Really enjoy working with her!!
Response from the owner:Thank you, Candy!
Premier knowledge and personal service. That's what you get when you work with Michelle at McPike Insurance. I'm a newbie to this Medicare world, only one year in. And still, products change SO quickly! After one year, Michelle knew where to steer me when my Insurance provider's costs exploded. She made a solid recommendation and got me going. She takes time to know your needs and also genuinely concerned. She's an expert. In fact, I steered my brother to select her for his Medicare plan. Thanks Michelle for what you do. Much appreciated!

– Eddy Cabello
Indianapolis
Response from the owner:It's been a pleasure helping you, Eddy!
Michelle is great! She does her research, comes prepared to take whatever time needed to explain the information clearly and then helps you choose the best option for you depending on your circumstances. Michelle made enrollment a lot less stressful.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Joy!
I reached out to Michelle to get help with insurance for my mom. Michelle was easy to work with, and responded quickly to all my questions(at multiple different times).
Response from the owner:Thank you for reaching out to me for help!
Michelle is pleasant, knowledgeable and easy to work with. I highly recommend her.
Response from the owner:Thank you, Greg!
always knowledgeable, can research saving better than most.Can manage unruly clients who have been left to suffer by others.Never afraid to refer others to her as a good source to help with insurance
Response from the owner:I appreciate your business and your referrals, Bob!
Mischelle's father was our Insurance agent and very knowledgeable. Mitchell has been able to fill some big shoes upon his retirement. She is just as knowledgeable and keeps up on the ever changing Medicare rules and regulations. She is a wonderful asset when trying to figure out all these changes and insurance options!
Response from the owner:I appreciate the kind words, Jenny!
yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7

Highly Recommend

March 5, 2025

Michelle is very conscientious, honest, intelligent, very responsive and got us the best deal for our needs after reviewing various companies . She is also very personable and drops everything to handle any immediate needs. I highly recommend her!

Rochelle Gerulski
Verified

Medicare Consultant

December 20, 2023

Michelle is excellent in her Medicare knowledge. She is professional, efficient and personable as well. She helped us greatly in choosing a Medicare Advantage plan. I would definitely call her again and I also give out her business cards to people facing this challenge:)

Kim Cunningham
Verified

Helpful in Time of Need

February 13, 2023

Michelle Morin was terrific. She helped Kevin and I when we needed it the most. She looked for the best options for us and explained them all very clearly.

She was there when we needed help and we are very appreciative of that.

Pam Barnhart
Verified

Makes Medicare Easy

February 10, 2023

Michelle helped me navigate the Medicare maze! She was more focused on making sure I got the coverage for my needs rather than selling a particular product. Once she understood my history and concerns, she found the right product for me at an affordable price. Michelle will be my agent for life!

Terri Bertrang
Verified

Response from McPike Insurance Agency

Thank you for taking the time to share your positive experience with McPike Insurance. We are thrilled to hear that we made your Medicare insurance process easy and stress-free. Your kind words mean a lot to us and we are grateful for your support.

Thank you again for choosing McPike Insurance.

Highly recommend McPike Insurance Agency

May 26, 2022

“I would highly recommend McPike Insurance Agency. Michelle came to my home and was so informative. She answered all my questions. I was so pleased with the services I received.”

SANDY P. - IN
Verified
Divider

Blog

We specialize in helping people understand the rights and options they have with Medicare.

Divider

Contact Us Today

Let us start helping you over the phone today.

There is no obligation, no high-pressure sales and you never pay extra to work with an agent!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Disclaimer

Plans are insured or covered by a Medicare Advantage (HMO, PPO and PFFS) organization with a Medicare contract and/or a Medicare-approved Part D sponsor. Enrollment in the plan depends on the plan’s contract renewal with Medicare.

When you call the number listed on this website, you will be directed to a licensed insurance sales agent or broker.

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent seven organizations which offer 57 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program to get information on all of your options

This website is a solicitation of insurance. By providing us with your contact information, you agree that an authorized representative or licensed insurance agent/producer may contact you by telephone, email or mail to answer your questions or provide additional information about Medicare Advantage, Part D or Medicare Supplement Insurance plans.